Why Your Startup Fails to Scale ($12B+ Founder Explains) | DevRev, Dheeraj Pandey
Meet Dheeraj Pandey, co-founder and CEO of DevRev. He grew up in one of the poorest towns in India, yet went on to lead the biggest US tech IPO of 2016. Then...
Watch on YouTube →Transcript
Intro
- 00:00A feature alone is not going to get me
- 00:02$100,000 from a customer. One of the
- 00:04reasons for our success is
- 00:05underpromising and overd delivering.
- 00:07This is the core of repeat business. If
- 00:09your existing customers are not paying
- 00:10you more, then you're basically just
- 00:12selling and running, which means hunt,
- 00:14hunt, hunt. But the balance between
- 00:16hunting and farming, which is new
- 00:18customers versus getting more from
- 00:20existing customers. Jeff Bezos has
- 00:22called it like the flywheel effect of
- 00:24companies. You know, you need to add new
- 00:26logos, but you need to go make money
- 00:28from existing logos. I think that tests
- 00:30the real metal of a company. I'm a big
- 00:32fan of Will Gdara is a restaurant tour
- 00:35who actually had two of the most famous
- 00:37restaurants in the world and he talks
- 00:39about this concept of unreasonable
- 00:41hospitality giving people way more than
- 00:44they expect. That is where great
- 00:47entrepreneurs differentiate from the
- 00:49mediocre ones.
- 00:56My name is Dhiraj Pande. I'm the
- 00:58co-founder and CEO of a company called
- 01:00DevRev. So we are in the business of
- 01:02blurring the lines between the public
- 01:04wisdom of the internet and natural
- 01:07language wisdom with the enterprise
- 01:09wisdom. That's basically what Devre is
- 01:11all about. Before this I had started a
- 01:13company nutanics. We were the fastest to
- 01:15a billion dollars in revenue and took it
- 01:18public in 7 years record time on NASDAQ
- 01:20was the largest tech IPO of 2016. I ran
- 01:22it as a public company CEO for almost 5
- 01:24years. Then I realized there's a big
- 01:26opportunity opening up in AI which is
- 01:28how dead started almost 4 years ago. I
- 01:30also sit on Adobe's board. I'm on the
- 01:32audit committee there. And last but not
- 01:34the least a big student of both AI and
- 01:37design.
Where a Founder's Journey Begins - From the Poorest State to a Billion-Dollar Path
- 01:41I had a fairly dysfunctional childhood.
- 01:43I grew up in the poorest state of India.
- 01:46The Himalayan rivers the seasonal rivers
- 01:48that would flood half the state. Half
- 01:50the year was flooded. It was the most
- 01:53lawless state but the poorest state.
- 01:55That state's GDP per capita is only as
- 01:58much as subsaharan Africa. So you can
- 02:00imagine the level of poverty that
- 02:02actually I saw. That's what catapulted
- 02:04me to actually get out of the state and
- 02:05do something. Back in the day you could
- 02:08only be a good engineer or a good
- 02:09doctor. There was no third profession. I
- 02:11picked engineering. Luckily when I was
- 02:14growing up and I had to pick uh the
- 02:16field of engineering the internet had
- 02:18just happened. This is 1993 1994.
- 02:20computer science was going to be the
- 02:22next hot thing just like AI which is the
- 02:24new computer science is hot right now I
- 02:26built my entire career just being shaped
- 02:28around the internet I can't stay in
- 02:30India right now but back in the day the
- 02:32only option was to leave the country if
- 02:35you're an engineer I have to be in this
- 02:37bubble to know what working in the
- 02:39industry means a big part of this is to
How a Dysfunctional Childhood Shapes a Founder’s Mindset
- 02:42have seen dysfunction as a child
- 02:45divorced is not bad enough I mean if
- 02:47you've seen sad and disappointing days
- 02:49as a higher. I think it actually carries
- 02:51through with you. But it also means you
- 02:53can actually take care of tough
- 02:54situations and entrepreneurship is a lot
- 02:57of that. It's a lot of highs and lows
- 02:59and it's important not to get too sad
- 03:01with the lows which also means that you
- 03:03can't be too happy with the highs and
- 03:05staying on that average line and how you
- 03:08modulate your emotion is the way you
- 03:11will deal with a lot of failures.
EO partner highlight
- 03:15I'm Taylor Rottwell, the founder and CEO
- 03:17of Laravel. Our mission is to help
- 03:20developers build, deploy, and monitor
- 03:22applications consistently and
- 03:23beautifully.
- 03:25Starting projects is great, but more
- 03:27importantly, you need to ship them.
- 03:28Great ideas mean nothing until they
- 03:30ship.
- 03:32That's exactly why I built Laravel, to
- 03:34bring your entire journey from idea to
- 03:36production into one seamless flow. It's
- 03:39more than a PHP framework. It's a
- 03:41complete connected ecosystem built for
- 03:43speed and confidence. We provide
- 03:46elegant, opinionated solutions for
- 03:48everything your modern web app needs.
- 03:50And you can deploy in under a minute
- 03:52with Laravel Cloud, straight from Git.
- 03:54Zero config needed. Laravel now powers
- 03:57nearly 600,000 lab websites, helping
- 04:00developers worldwide ship their ideas
- 04:02faster.
- 04:04Build with elegance. Deploy with
- 04:06confidence. Monitor with precision.
- 04:08Stop configuring. Start shipping. Visit
- 04:11larave.com today.
How the Biggest US Tech IPO Took Him Back to Day One
- 04:19only direction when you start a company
- 04:22is forward. That's the best you can do.
- 04:25I can't thank you enough. I mean, I'm
- 04:26I'm not going to
- 04:27Nutanics was my first startup. I think
- 04:29the core of Nutanix was to really do
- 04:32something around data management. We
- 04:34said, look, we are good at data inensive
- 04:37applications. We reliably manage data at
- 04:41fast speeds like no one else. Hey, we
- 04:43can ship software to you where your data
- 04:46centers will look like Google's and
- 04:48Amazons and Facebooks and so on. And we
- 04:51were also trying to bring commodity
- 04:52hardware which was Taiwanese equipment
- 04:54to the enterprise. Before that, people
- 04:56were buying hardware from Dell, HP, IBM,
- 05:00all these branded hardware companies,
- 05:03EMC, NetApp. So, they were all into
- 05:06shiny hardware. And he like no, no, no,
- 05:08no. You can take the same approach that
- 05:10Amazon, Google, Facebook take really
- 05:12source hardware from Taiwan, bring it to
- 05:15the US and put software on top. So you
- 05:18have a commodity hardware and a pure
- 05:20software running on top of it. First
- 05:22four five years was extremely
- 05:24problematic because the hardware was
- 05:26flaky and unreliable and the software
- 05:28needed to overcompensate for that. So we
- 05:31took our time to really make the
- 05:32software compensate for a flaky fragile
- 05:35hardware. In fact, our company was
- 05:36always shut down three times. But at the
- 05:39core, the big thing in my head was that
- 05:42you are on a tight rope and you're
- 05:44walking a tight rope and you have to
Founders Walk a Tightrope - Never Turn Around
- 05:46cross this valley. When you're halfway
- 05:49through, you can't turn around. You'll
- 05:51fall if you turn around. Any new product
- 05:53that you launch, any new initiative, you
- 05:56have to think about plowing through.
- 05:57Now, sometimes moving forward might mean
- 06:00shutting it down completely. But to
- 06:02actually say I want to go back this
- 06:04direction is the worst thing that
- 06:05entrepreneurs actually do. So we did
- 06:07have a couple of big pivots. The only
- 06:09constant in building a company is
- 06:12change. So if you can embrace change and
- 06:14you can make it seamless and you can be
- 06:16a little bit ahead of the market and you
- 06:18have to be really good at looking around
- 06:19the corner and that means listening
- 06:21because when you hear something from the
- 06:23market the first time as a stubborn
- 06:25entrepreneur you'll say h that's an
- 06:27aberration. When you hear it the second
- 06:29time, now it's a coincidence. When you
- 06:33hear it a third time, it's a pattern.
- 06:35You need to understand how to recognize
- 06:37patterns and look around the corner. Be
- 06:40at least 6 months ahead of what
- 06:42eventually will be a hard pivot and see
- 06:45if you can make soft pivots into that
- 06:47direction. There's no point just making
- 06:4990° turns or 180° turns if you can
- 06:51actually make softer turns to the same
- 06:54degree that he would have otherwise
- 06:55achieved.
- 06:57I think if you look at the idea of
Don’t Go Where the Puck Is. Go Where It’s Going
- 07:00nutanics, it was where the puck was as
- 07:03opposed to where the puck was headed
- 07:04because it my the first idea my first
- 07:06startup. I had started to really take
- 07:09technology risk but not a market risk
- 07:11cuz the market by 2012 had already seen
- 07:14cloud and the fact that consumer cloud
- 07:16companies were saying look you don't
- 07:18need to own infrastructure if you can
- 07:19stream the infrastructure. It's like
- 07:21what happened with music eventually was
- 07:23like you don't need to own songs. market
- 07:25for Spotify was already happening and
- 07:27the public cloud was that version for
- 07:29infrastructure. So the puck was headed
- 07:31to streaming and we were still at iTunes
- 07:33and on software was basically headed in
- 07:37that challenge market where you would
- 07:39constantly have to think about do I need
- 07:40to own or can I stream do I need to own
- 07:42can I stream so the idea of nutanics was
- 07:45where the puck was and it was a
- 07:48technology risk and we got paid for it
- 07:49for 1020 $20 million that's the
- 07:51valuation of nanic but to really build a
To Build a Big Business, Take Market Risk
- 07:53hundred billion business you had to take
- 07:55a market risk
- 08:00This is something that all entrepreneurs
- 08:01will actually face being an investor but
- 08:03also being an operator and when you do
- 08:05your company you're doing both in one at
- 08:07some point you might have to decouple
- 08:09those where you become an investor in
- 08:11your current idea and you become an
- 08:13operator of a new idea around 2020 when
- 08:16co happened is when you're like okay
- 08:17what's the next chemistry we can bring
- 08:19together and it really happened to be
- 08:21around business software when GPT came
- 08:23about by this time we already had our
- 08:27own vector database. We had built our
- 08:29own vector database to actually do
- 08:31search because we knew search was the
- 08:34first killer app for anything
- 08:36intelligent. Now what GPT has given us
- 08:39is the ability to ask it questions and
- 08:43bring the natural language wisdom that
- 08:45otherwise we would have struggled to
- 08:46build. But at the core of it, the
- 08:49enterprise data piece of it is the
- 08:51biggest challenge cuz I can't do
- 08:53anything in the in the business in a in
- 08:54an enterprise software environment with
- 08:56Wikipedia's knowledge or internet's
- 08:58knowledge. I need to bring the knowledge
- 09:00of the enterprise in a coherent hole
- 09:03which is what a knowledge graph actually
- 09:04brings. And to take this knowledge graph
- 09:07and mix it up with the wisdom of the
- 09:09internet is what we really do. So the
- 09:12biggest bang for AI is building a
- 09:15perplexity like thing for all enterprise
- 09:19assets. And that to me was the light
- 09:21bulb moment. In the absence of the
- 09:23public cloud, we could have been a
- 09:25hundred billion company. But in the
- 09:27presence of the public cloud, we'd be
- 09:29hovering around the $20 billion range,
- 09:31you know, because the market has moved.
- 09:34If technology doesn't integrate things,
- 09:36bring the chemistry as opposed to just
- 09:38new features and new ideas, it has not
- 09:41done its job. A big ideas are about
- 09:44alchemy. It's about mixing things
- 09:45together and making it look like a more
- 09:47robust solution. Even like a chemical
- 09:49solution is about bringing chemistry
- 09:52together. And bringing a lot of these
- 09:54things together is where a lot of uh
- 09:56value gets created.
- 09:58Product market fit is actually a
Product-Market Fit is a journey, not a destination
- 10:00journey, not a destination. You'll need
- 10:02to struggle with that. At 1 million, at
- 10:0410 million, at 50 million, at 100
- 10:06million, at a quarter billion, at half a
- 10:08billion, a billion, every such
- 10:10milestone, you have to keep thinking
- 10:12again. You have to think ahead of the
- 10:14curve because if you waited too long,
- 10:16you might start to sputter at 100
- 10:18million. You might have needed a new
- 10:19product for going from 100 million to
- 10:21250 million. And you might need have
- 10:23needed to see the new region of the
- 10:25world to do sales and marketing. I think
- 10:27this idea of PMF is relative and it's
- 10:30not a destination. Every time you think
- 10:32you have product market fit, you will
- 10:34start to sputter at the next threshold.
- 10:35So at 10 million, you're like, "Okay, I
- 10:37have PMF." That means that you not
- 10:39thought through that at 50 million, you
- 10:41will stall because you didn't have a
- 10:42pipeline that was large enough for more
- 10:45features, more capabilities, bigger
- 10:46deals, bigger customers, or you didn't
- 10:49think hard enough about the other
- 10:50regions of the world, which will now
- 10:52create a portfolio effect. Because what
- 10:55he keep me to doing is to create a
- 10:57portfolio of products of customers of
- 11:00regions of the world, geographies around
- 11:02the world that will give you that
- 11:03balance every quarter because not every
- 11:05existing customer will pay you every
- 11:07quarter. So you need to find a portfolio
- 11:09of large customers so that they can all
- 11:11balance each other every quarter. I
- 11:13think that to me is a journey more than
- 11:15a destination.
The One Thing Behind Every $100B Deal
- 11:20We take a step back and think about the
- 11:22funnel of idea and the life cycle of an
- 11:24idea. There's a lot of ideas up there at
- 11:26the top of the funnel and then they
- 11:28become concepts. From concepts when it
- 11:31becomes a little bit real, it's still a
- 11:33feature. You talk about all these
- 11:34companies that are basically building
- 11:36agents, but at best they're features and
- 11:38you can get some early wins by showing a
- 11:40feature to your customer, but how do you
- 11:42take a feature to a product? A feature
- 11:44alone is not going to get me $100,000
- 11:46from a customer. How do you organize all
- 11:48this into a robust product and a product
- 11:51to a company and a company to a
- 11:53business? That is the real test of
- 11:56entrepreneurship. Going from a company
- 11:58to a business is now really building
- 12:00relationships with customers, making
- 12:01sure that you don't leave customers in
- 12:04the lurch when they need the most amount
- 12:05of help. One of the reasons for our
- 12:07success is underpromising and overd
Underpromise and Overdeliver – The Core of Repeat Business
- 12:09delivering, you know, and this is the
- 12:10core of repeat business. If your
- 12:12existing customers are not paying you
- 12:13more, then you're basically just selling
- 12:16and running, which means hunt, hunt,
- 12:18hunt. But the balance between hunting
- 12:19and farming, which is new customers
- 12:22versus getting more from existing
- 12:24customers, is at the core of building
- 12:26large businesses. You know, Jeff Bezos
- 12:28has called it like the flywheel effect
- 12:29of companies. You know, you need to add
The Flywheel Effect of a Company
- 12:31new logos, but you need to go make money
- 12:33from existing logos. I think that tests
- 12:35the real metal of a company. Do you have
- 12:37a product that is authentic? You have
- 12:40customer support that's really good and
- 12:42finally you have salespeople who really
- 12:44know how to underpromise and overd
- 12:45deliver. I'm a big fan of Will Gdara is
- 12:48a restaurant tour who actually had two
- 12:50of the most famous restaurants in the
- 12:52world and he talks about this concept of
- 12:55unreasonable hospitality giving people
Why Every Founder Should Practice Unreasonable Hospitality
- 12:57way more than they expect. That is where
- 13:01great entrepreneurs differentiate from
- 13:03the mediocre ones. I think a lot of
- 13:05people think that entrepreneurship is
- 13:06about selling, selling, selling your
- 13:08dreams and ideas to prospective
- 13:10candidates who become employees of your
- 13:12company, but also prospective customers
- 13:14and partners. Very few people, I would
- 13:16say less than a percent of the people
- 13:18are really good at following through.
- 13:20They'll sell and they'll move on and
- 13:21they'll sell some more and they'll move
- 13:22on as opposed to selling and staying. I
- 13:25think that idea of unreasonable
- 13:27hospitality is what really creates the
- 13:29flywheel. When you go to a new
- 13:32customers, they hear from existing
- 13:34customers and that's how you reduce the
- 13:36friction. At the end of the day, there's
- 13:37two emotions going on in a new
Fear of Missing Out vs Fear of Messing Up
- 13:40relationship. The fear of missing out,
- 13:41but also the fear of messing up. FOMO
- 13:44and FOMO as we call it. And a lot of
- 13:46people think that they just need to
- 13:48create for more with prospects. But they
- 13:51don't realize that most customers,
- 13:53especially in B2B, I'm talking about B2B
- 13:54software, when you're really doing
- 13:56larger deals like $50, $100, $200,000. A
- 13:59lot of it is actually based on faux
- 14:01mean, which is fear of messing up. So
- 14:04building that critical relationship and
- 14:06providing that unreasonable hospitality
- 14:08and letting your existing customers
- 14:11speak of that unreasonable hospitality
- 14:13is the only way to blunt that emotion of
- 14:17fear of messing up. To me,
- 14:19entrepreneurship is about building that
- 14:21authenticity at every level of the way
- 14:24because the market is actually smarter
- 14:26than you think.
The Future of Enterprise SaaS
- 14:30What is disruptive in technology? The
- 14:33biggest disruptor to technology is
- 14:35miniaturization.
- 14:36Big things into small things. Literate
- 14:39sits in a pocket. No one on a desk. I
- 14:41mean, even the idea of infrastructure
- 14:43was like that. Oh, we buying things for
- 14:445 years. big metal monolithic purchases
- 14:47like just come and use the compute for 2
- 14:50hours if that's what it takes for you
- 14:52when you make things smaller and lighter
- 14:53weight that is the biggest disruptor to
- 14:55incumbents SAS has become extremely
- 14:58heavyweight extremely
- 15:01complex in terms of implementation so
- 15:03the disruption that will happen is
- 15:06consumption we go from subscription to
- 15:08consumption and consumption models is
- 15:11what will disrupt subscription models
- 15:14remember subscription Subscription
- 15:15models disrupted licensing models of the
- 15:18last 20 years before that where people
- 15:19are buying 5 years enterprise license
- 15:22agreements we move to subscription we
- 15:24said hey you can pay by the user then
- 15:26slack comes in there you don't have to
- 15:27pay by the user you can pay by the
- 15:29monthly active user making it even more
- 15:31lightweight and a little bit more
- 15:33towards consumption snowflake coming in
- 15:35saying everything consumption based I
- 15:38think all SAS will probably become
- 15:40consumptionbased and that will disrupt
- 15:43legacy SAS
The Worst Decision an Entrepreneur Can Make
- 15:47And the worst decision that people
- 15:48should not take is sit on things for too
- 15:52long. Sit on people who are not a good
- 15:54fit for too long. Bad products, unhappy
- 15:57customers, unhappy employees, mediocre
- 16:00leaders. So to me, sitting on the
- 16:03suboptimal thing for too long is the
- 16:05worst thing that can happen. It's the
- 16:07tyranny of mediocrity. not changing and
- 16:10do nothing. Which is exactly what you
- 16:13have to go and fight when you go and
- 16:15sell your new idea to customers because
- 16:17customers most comfortable thing is to
- 16:20do nothing. And your biggest competition
- 16:21is not that other idea, the other
- 16:24competitor. Your biggest competitor is
- 16:27inertia. And that is also the biggest
- 16:29enemy within a company. Do nothing.
- 16:31That's the worst thing uh an
- 16:33entrepreneur can do. That's the worst
- 16:34thing a company can do.