Foods to Boost Metabolism & Lose Weight | Dr. Marie-Pierre St-Onge & Dr. Andrew Huberman
Dr. Marie-Pierre St-Onge and Dr. Andrew Huberman discuss the impact of functional foods on metabolism, highlighting how ginger can increase the thermic effect of food and the nuanced effects of fermented dairy and coffee-derived oligosaccharides on body composition.
Watch on YouTube →Transcript
Kefir & Cholesterol Studies
- 00:00Let's talk about food and nutrients.
- 00:02You've done a substantial amount of work
- 00:03here in this area and I have a bunch of
- 00:05questions, but first I want to talk
- 00:07about kefir.
- 00:08Yeah.
- 00:09I love Bulgarian full fat plain yogurt,
- 00:12but it's right next to the kefir.
- 00:14Uhhuh.
- 00:14And I'm always like, do I get the kefir?
- 00:16Well, I don't know. I love the Bulgarian
- 00:17full fat plain yogurt. So, I haven't
- 00:19tried the kefir yet. What's special
- 00:20about kefir and why why did you study
- 00:22kefir?
- 00:23Kefir we we studied because it was a
- 00:26fermented dairy product. uh probiotics.
- 00:29We figured, you know, maybe it will
- 00:31improve uh cholesterol synthesis based
- 00:34on its impact on short- chain fatty
- 00:36acids. So, that was at the the subject
- 00:38of my master's thesis.
- 00:41And for that study, uh that was when I
- 00:43was at McGill. We recruited men that had
- 00:47mildly elevated cholesterol levels. We
- 00:49gave them two cups per day versus just
- 00:52regular milk for a month. So two cups
- 00:55like two mugs like this.
- 00:57Two cups like the measuring cup.
- 00:59Okay.
- 00:59Yeah.
- 01:00Okay.
- 01:00Um like 500 mls.
- 01:02Okay.
- 01:03And uh and we measured their the amount
- 01:07of cholesterol they they produced at
- 01:10baseline endpoint in both phases and
- 01:14there was no effect. It was a null study
- 01:16was one of those. It was hard to get
- 01:19published.
- 01:20Kept at it and and we got it published
- 01:23but yeah. So these fermented yogurts and
- 01:26things they don't do anything for for
- 01:28cholesterol levels
- 01:29at least in our study in this population
- 01:32at this level with this comparison
- 01:35didn't have any effect.
- 01:36What's your general thought about uh low
- 01:38sugar fermented foods? I don't know if
- 01:39kefir uh qualifies as low sugar, but
- 01:42based on Justin Sonnenberg's work at
- 01:44Stanford and others, I've been I've been
- 01:46really bullish on this idea of
- 01:48sauerkraut, kimchi,
- 01:50uh full fat Bulgarian yogurt. Fermented
- 01:53foods are are interesting.
- 01:55Yeah.
- 01:55Are you a proponent in general?
- 01:57I'm a proponent. Yeah, absolutely. I
- 01:59think it's important to feed your gut. I
- 02:01think that uh the gut microbiome is uh
- 02:04getting a lot of attention for all sorts
- 02:05of, you know, uh health benefits.
- 02:09So I think that that's something that's
- 02:11uh that's is important. So also it's
- 02:13important to also consider that you know
- 02:16for that study right our main outcome
- 02:19was cholesterol synthesis but there's so
- 02:22many other things we could have looked
- 02:24at that we didn't look at right then
- 02:26maybe it didn't have any impact for
- 02:28cholesterol synthesis but maybe
- 02:33glycemic control might be better or for
- 02:38gut inflammation it would be better but
- 02:41you know You you pick your outcomes,
- 02:42right? You study something and
- 02:44this is the challenge of doing
- 02:45controlled science. Yeah. Yeah. Sort of
- 02:48the opposite end of the like X what used
- 02:51to be called Twitter science where like
- 02:52people just like report anecdotes but
- 02:56actually anecdotes of that sort of
- 02:57become very powerful now in the public
- 02:59health space for better or worse like
- 03:00people you know because
- 03:02I we can look at any study and say well
- 03:04that's a very artificial circumstance.
- 03:06You say, "Well, intentionally, because
- 03:07we're trying to isolate variables,
- 03:10people get frustrated." Oh, that's an
- 03:12observational study. Well, I'm going to
- 03:15continue to eat low sugar fermented
- 03:16foods every day. I I I do think in a
- 03:19study like the one you described,
- 03:21occasionally there's just there's, let
- 03:23me state this differently. Historically
Coffee & Weight Loss
- 03:26in science, there's been a lot of
- 03:28interesting discoveries that have come
- 03:29from researchers designing a study to
- 03:32look at one thing and then kind of
- 03:33noticing, oh, like all the subjects feel
- 03:36better or sleep better, their skin, they
- 03:38they're reporting things that then lead
- 03:40to another
- 03:41another line line of inquiry. But you
- 03:44moved on from Kefir. Tell me about this
- 03:46um this paper. I was intrigued by this
- 03:48when I looked over your CV. A uh a
- 03:51weight loss diet that includes a coffee
- 03:53beverage enriched in let me try this
- 03:55menolosaccharides.
- 03:57Yeah.
- 03:58Okay. Long word leads to a greater loss
- 04:00of atapose fat tissue than placebo
- 04:03beverage in overweight men.
- 04:05Y
- 04:05tell me about this study and what these
- 04:07men oligosaccharides are and if somebody
- 04:11wants to lose weight should they be
- 04:12including this in their coffee?
- 04:14So this was industry sponsored research
- 04:16that I did. um they wanted to replicate
- 04:18a study that had been done in a
- 04:21different country because they wanted to
- 04:23replicate the findings. So we did this
- 04:25study uh it was basically a placeboc
- 04:28controlled study. We got we were
- 04:30provided um coffee manualsaccharides. So
- 04:33these are extracted from spent coffee
- 04:36grounds. So it was basically satchets
- 04:38right? So a white packet one had the cap
- 04:42coffee manualsaccharides the other one
- 04:44didn't. We gave it to our study
- 04:46participants. We measured their body
- 04:48composition. We found an effect on body
- 04:52composition in men, not in women.
- 04:54And so that was the end of that product.
- 04:56Really? They wouldn't market it just
- 04:57because it only had an effect in men.
- 04:59Yeah. Yeah.
- 05:00I assure you there are many men who
- 05:01would love to drink a coffee drink and
- 05:02lose more weight as a consequence.
- 05:04It's not going to be our market, you
- 05:05know.
- 05:06But do we know what the ingredients
- 05:07were?
- 05:08It was manualsaccharides.
- 05:10Extracted. Yeah. Uh so it was just uh
- 05:12basically uh a product that was tasted
- 05:16like coffee, strong coffee, but it
- 05:19didn't have the caffeine or anything
- 05:20like that. It just had this this
- 05:22manosaccharide that was extracted from
- 05:24coffee.
- 05:26So this substance comes from coffee
- 05:28ordinarily.
- 05:29But coffee is very low low calorie on
- 05:32its own,
- 05:32but it's from the spent ground. So you
- 05:34no one really consumes this really
- 05:37because you know when you brew your
- 05:39coffee you're
- 05:41you're not getting it. No.
- 05:42Can you buy it? Can people get it?
- 05:45I don't think so.
- 05:46So
- 05:47what what do you First of all, how much
- 05:49weight did they lose relative to the
- 05:50It was statistically significant. Yeah.
- 05:53Okay. I was intrigued by it because I
- 05:54thought there there's something that I
- 05:56mean you studied it's interesting you
- 05:58studied kefir menolosaccharides from
- 06:01coffee. Yeah. And now I'm going to ask
- 06:02you about ginger.
- 06:03Well, when I was a graduate student, I
- 06:05was interested in functional foods
Defining Functional Health Claims
- 06:08and I was interested in those foods that
- 06:10provide health benefits beyond their
- 06:13nutritional value.
- 06:14Right? So, keir is a fermented dairy
- 06:18product. It would we were studying it
- 06:21for its a functional benefit on
- 06:23cholesterol synthesis. That's not a uh
- 06:28that's not a function of dairy, right?
- 06:30Dairy is you consume it for bone health,
- 06:34right? So it's basically when we talk
- 06:36about different claims that foods have,
- 06:38you know, there's those structure
- 06:39function claims like consuming dairy
- 06:42contains calcium that's good for your
- 06:44bones and then there's um functional
- 06:48claims, those functional claims or
- 06:49health claims we call them that say okay
- 06:51well health claim there's a health claim
- 06:53for oats for example, right? So
- 06:55consuming fiber from oats uh reduces
- 06:58cholesterol levels.
- 06:59That's been demonstrated.
- 07:01Yes. So that's that's a health claim.
- 07:03That's an approved health claim. That's
- 07:05why you see the hearts on some boxes of
- 07:07cereal. But that's different than fiber
- 07:12is good for maintaining regularity.
- 07:15Right? So anyways, I was interested in
- 07:16in functional foods for health benefits
- 07:19beyond their their nutritional content.
- 07:22And so uh we we studied kefir for I
- 07:26studied kefir for my master's degree and
- 07:27then for my PhD studied uh mediumchain
- 07:31triglycerides
- 07:32um and then um ginger that was uh that
- 07:37was something that I that I uh offered
- 07:39to a grad student at Colombia. It was
- 07:42interesting because uh the McCormick
- 07:44company
- 07:46had an advertisement in uh one of the
- 07:48nutrition journals and they were going
- 07:50to donate
- 07:52um spices for research. I was like,
Ginger & Energy Expenditure
- 07:54"Okay." They had a list of different
- 07:56herbs and spices that they were going to
- 07:58donate for research. And I had a grad
- 08:00student and I said, "Take a look at this
- 08:02list. Come back to me, say if there's
- 08:05something in there that we should test
- 08:08in the lab based on the things that I
- 08:10do. Don't come to me with something
- 08:12that's, you know, that I don't study."
- 08:14But, and then he did some research and
- 08:17he came back. He said, "I think we
- 08:18should study ginger." I'm like, "Okay."
- 08:20And to do what? like I think you know
- 08:22for energy expenditure looking at
- 08:25thermic effect of food like okay so so
- 08:28we did this study I had some some funds
- 08:31that I could use for him to do that and
- 08:33uh
- 08:33what did the study look like
- 08:34a study where we looked at the thermic
- 08:36effect of food
- 08:36like so people ate ginger root spicing
- 08:39their food
- 08:40we dissolved ginger powder in warm water
- 08:45and so that was one beverage and then uh
- 08:47in the crossover again crossover design
- 08:50so next time when they came it just hot
- 08:52water.
- 08:52And how many times a day are they
- 08:53drinking it?
- 08:54This was a one time one time uh
- 08:57consumption period. And we looked at the
- 08:59thermic effect of food over a six-hour
- 09:01period. So again, they're they're under
- 09:03this um we call it a metabolic hood,
- 09:06right? So a little bubble and we measure
- 09:09their uh oxygen consumption, carbon
- 09:11dioxide production for I think it was
- 09:13four or five hours
- 09:14and it's significantly elevated.
- 09:16Mhm.
- 09:16With ginger.
- 09:17With ginger.
- 09:18Yeah.
- 09:19Wow. So we think through the capsain
- 09:21receptor there's an increase in the
- 09:23thermic effect of food. So yeah, so I
- 09:25was interested to see are there little
- 09:28things that we could do, little changes
- 09:30we can make to our diet to boost energy
- 09:33expenditure relative to intake, you
- 09:35know, just to tip the scale because many
- 09:39adults over the course of their life
- 09:40lifetime gain weight. And it's not a big
- 09:45imbalance in calories on a daily basis
- 09:48that leads to
- 09:5010 lbs of weight gain over 10, 15 years,
- 09:53right?